Newsletter

Remembrance, a diplomatic instrument

Ceremony in memory of the 117 French soldiers killed in captivity in 1871, Kaditz cemetery, Dresden, 10 May 2021. © Denk Mal Fort! e.V. - Die Erinnerungswerkstatt Dresden

Responsible for preserving and developing French defence interests in Germany, General Metz presents the distinctive features and diplomatic impacts of shared Franco-German memory. Constantly in touch with his German counterparts, every year he carries out a series of actions to keep that memory alive.

 

A story of Franco-German reconciliation

Signing of the Treaty of Aachen by French president Emmanuel Macron and German chancellor Angela Merkel, 22 January 2019. © Présidence de la République

From the origins of the Franco-Prussian War to the present, Franco-German relations have seen many ups and downs, and the two world wars symbolised the ultimate break in relations. The late 20th century was a time for peace, and paved the way for a genuine process of reconciliation. Thus, while bilateral relations between Germany and France may be the result of years of progressive and intense cooperation, they are also indissociable from European integration.

The practices

The practices

Links: Besucher des Holocaust-Mahnmals in Berlin, 25. Mai 2020. © John Macdougall/AFP. Rechts: Besucher des Holocaust-Mahnmals in Paris. © Rechte vorbehalten

The study of the different forms of remembrance is intrinsically linked to that of commemorative practices. As such, the same methods are used in France and Germany. Both countries honour and commemorate by creating special days and erecting memorials; pay tribute through the actions of patriotic societies and battlefield pilgrimage organisations; attach value by building military cemeteries; and educate by opening museums and interpretation centres devoted to each conflict. Indeed, although remembrance always involves the organisation of highly ritualised official ceremonies, built around the presence of civilian and military officials according to a strict protocol, practices are continually changing. There is often an implicit desire to educate the general public and raise awareness among young people by drawing their attention to an aspect of history in order to pass on values that can shed light on the present and help build the future.

Memorial to Chartres

Cover of Mémorial de Chartres : le drame de 1940 en noirs et blancs. © Éditions L’Harmattan

A member of the advisory board of the review Allemagne d’Aujourd’hui (Germany Today), Gérard Valin presents his play, Mémorial de Chartres : le drame de 1940 en noirs et blancs (Memorial to Chartres: the drama of 1940 in black and white). Divided into ten scenes and with a cast of five men and one woman, the play enacts a story based on military archives, official speeches and reports from combat units. Yet the events evoke a little-known episode of the Second World War.

 

Sites to be preserved and understood

Young people visit the Neuengamme camp, 11 February 2012. © Rights reserved

From Montluc prison in France to Neuengamme concentration camp in Germany, there is a Franco-Germany history to be told, and staff at the sites work together today to ensure that this profoundly European memory is passed on and understood.

The disappeared of the Algerian War

Conscripts in the Algerian War

Teaching and passing on the Great War

A French secondary-school student from Gap works on a caricature conserved at the Museum of Osnabrück. © Collège Centre, Gap

Rainer Bendick has written a thesis on how the First World War is represented in French and German school textbooks. Since 2018, he has been educational adviser to the Volksbund Deutsche Kriegsgräberfürsorge (VDK), the German war graves commission, in the Brunswick area. A former educational adviser to France’s First World War Centenary Commission, Alexandre Lafon is today a high-school teacher and associate researcher at Toulouse Jean Jaurès University.

 

German remembrance tourism in Normandy

The German military cemetery at La Cambe (Calvados), 10 June 2013. © David Major

Normandy’s number-four tourist nationality, the Germans come mainly to enjoy the beaches, countryside, heritage and gastronomy. Although history – in particular, Second World War history – is also one of their motivations, the number of German visitors to the region’s remembrance sites is estimated to be only 300 000. Getting them to go there remains a challenge for the regional authority.

 

Hubert Germain, the last Companion of Liberation

The last of the 1,038 “Companions of Liberation”, who passed away on Tuesday 12 October 2021, was buried on 11 November in the crypt of the Memorial of Combatant France, on Mont Valérien. He joins the remains of the 16 war dead who represent the diversity of French engagements during the Second World War. 

Ceremonies in tribute to the last Companion of Liberation on Wednesday 10 and Thursday 11 November.

Press release issued by the Musée de l'Ordre de la Libération

 


A national tribute was paid to Hubert Germain in the main courtyard of the Hôtel des Invalides, on Friday 15 October.

Click here to watch the video of the official ceremony


Developing tourism to remembrance sites

The beach of Arromanches (Normandy) on the 70th anniversary of the D-Day landings, June 2014. © Calvados Attractivité

Remembrance sites in France are seeing an unprecedented rise in visitor numbers, driven by recent improvement works to mark the anniversaries of the two world wars. This tourism development differs significantly from Germany, where managing the traces of the recent past raises countless questions.

New ways to commemorate in France

Filming and live broadcast on social media of the 70th anniversary of the UN French Battalion’s participation in the Korean War, Paris, 18 May 2021. © Maurice Bleicher

For over a hundred years, France’s remembrance policy has been structured around “national days”, mostly set by law, and ceremonies to mark the anniversaries of historic events as part of annual themes. Today, with fewer and fewer survivors of 20th-century conflicts still with us, commemorations are taking on new, more up-to-date forms, to rise to the challenge of passing on their memory.

Military remembrance in the Federal Republic of Germany

Oath-swearing ceremony of new recruits at the Bellevue Palace, Berlin, the official residence of the German president, with Covid social-distancing restrictions. © Ministry of Defence, Federal Republic of Germany

Recalling at times the country at its darkest hours, military remembrance in the Federal Republic of Germany is embodied today in two symbolic dates. Direct heir to that history, the Bundeswehr, the present-day name of the country’s armed forces, has managed to reconcile itself to the origins of that remembrance culture and accept its specificities.

National commemorations in Germany

Cérémonie devant le monument aux morts de la Bundeswehr situé dans l’enceinte du ministère de la défense à Berlin. © Ministère de la défense de la République fédérale d’Allemagne

While France’s commemorative calendar centres around 11 national holidays in honour of contemporary conflicts, across the Rhine there are only five, in addition to Germany’s national day. There is also room in German remembrance programming for other commemorative dates, which vary from year to year according to the anniversaries being celebrated. This occurs at different levels, in line with a highly specific protocol and rules.

German veteran policy post-1955

The first veterans’ badges are awarded by the German Minister of Defence, Ursula von der Leyen, at Fassberg air base, 15 June 2019. © Reservistenverband/Sören Peters

Although the policy of reparation and recognition for veterans was abruptly interrupted in the wake of the Second World War in Germany, it has been resumed in recent years for service personnel deployed on overseas operations.

Wehrmacht veterans in post-war Germany

The Nuremberg war trials, by the Allied military tribunal (20 November 1945 to 1 October 1946). © akg-images

In Germany, in view of the crimes committed by the Wehrmacht during the Second World War, there immediately arose, post-1945, the question of what place general officers should occupy in the armed forces and in German society, as the country was split in two by the Cold War.

Veteran policy since the First World War in France

A veteran’s card. © Collection Maurice Bleicher

In France, the catastrophe of the First World War laid the foundations for veteran policy as we still know it today.  It is based on the linked principles of reparation, recognition and solidarity, and is implemented in close partnership with the voluntary sector.

Attaching value to remembrance heritage in France

L’Opéra National Cemetery, Souain-Perthes-lès-Hurlus. © Guillaume Pichard

In France, besides the upkeep of the war graves, the Ministry of the Armed Forces has for a number of years now had an ambitious policy in place to renovate the 275 national cemeteries, 2 200 military plots across the country and the 1 000 French military burial places in nearly 80 countries, emblematic sites for honouring and preserving memory.

Maintaining the graves

French and German youth work parties on the battlefield of Hartmannswillerkopf. © VDK

In France, the landscape bears the mark of the two world wars that were fought on its soil. In particular, the military cemeteries are an invitation to remember, honour and reflect. In addition to the French graves maintained by the Office National des Anciens Combattants et Victimes de Guerre (ONAC-VG), France has many German cemeteries that are managed by the Volksbund Deutsche Kriegsgräberfürsorge (VDK).

 

The remembrances

The remembrances

Links: Einmarsch der alliierten Truppen in Paris, 25. August 1944. © akg-images Rechts: Rückkehr von Zivilisten in das zerstörte Berlin, 1945. © akg-images

Germany and France fought one another three times in 75 years, but the inherited memories of those conflicts are by no means identical. Indeed, the account of the victors cannot be compared with that of the defeated. The Franco-Prussian War was a truly traumatic experience for the French, whereas the Germans saw it as a crushing victory. For each conflict that followed, the watchword would often be to remember the successes, the sacrifices, the key battles in which the armies fought heroically, or to pay tribute to the many victims. Occasionally, the chosen path would be that of repentance. This dissonance of accounts can also be explained by the fact that some were “endorsed”, either by a strategic State or just by popular enthusiasm. Lastly, it is the result of a phenomenon whereby some memories are written in the present. This second section aims to shed light on the development and distinctive characteristics of remembrance of contemporary conflicts in France and Germany, while also setting out the commemorative challenges of tomorrow.